3 stars · fiction · history · Uncategorized

“City of Women” was a disappointment


City of Women

author : david r. gillham

pages : [hardcover] 392

summary :

It is 1943—the height of the Second World War. With the men away at the front, Berlin has become a city of women.

On the surface, Sigrid Schröder is the model German soldier’s wife: She goes to work every day, does as much with her rations as she can, and dutifully cares for her meddling mother-in-law, all the while ignoring the horrific immoralities of the regime.

But behind this façade is an entirely different Sigrid, a woman of passion who dreams of her former Jewish lover, now lost in the chaos of the war. But Sigrid is not the only one with secrets—she soon finds herself caught between what is right and what is wrong, and what falls somewhere in the shadows between the two…

review :

I was really excited to read this book because I have a fascination with reading books that take place during the WWII time period. This was much different from most other books that I’ve read because it was set in Berlin and barely had any mention of any battles or fighting apart from the occasional bombing coming from English planes overhead. Instead, most of the action is fixated on those who have been left behind in the city as every able man has been sent to fight. Most are in Russia, either never coming back to their families or returning as broken men physically and/or mentally. Citizens are starving. The Gestapo is everywhere. Sigrid learns, repeatedly, that there is nothing else more important in this version of Berlin than being a good German woman.

The book’s characters are those apart from the war. The women and children, mostly, as well as men either too old or injured to fight. And, worse than those left behind are those that are hunted. Any Jewish person, as well as anyone who fights to protect them or who speaks against Germany or the Gestapo. Sigrid, in the very beginning of the novel, is only concerned with herself. Her life is very boring. She doesn’t seem to even mildly like her husband and now she’s forced to live alone with his cranky elderly mother. Still, I always felt detached from her, never very sympathetic. Perhaps it was because I never got an explanation as to why she decided to marry her husband. Social pressure? Real love? I had no inkling of what her true feelings were like throughout most of this book.

That was made even more complex when she constantly dreams for the passion and love she holds for the lover she had taken years before, who is Jewish and has disappeared from her life. The things he does and says makes him everything but romantic to me. I felt pity for Sigrid because of her romantic options. There were no good options. But she kept pining after this man who was more terrible to her than her actual husband was.

I feel like this book had some interesting concepts, but the meandering way in which it was told made it seem much longer than it is–and it’s already a huge book. There were some very interesting details about how people would smuggle their friends or even strangers who were on the run and trying to get out of Germany. I liked the intrigue there, the danger. But there was little build-up to the conclusion of this book, which seemed to come out of nowhere. All of a sudden Sigrid was a completely different character, whereas in the hundreds of pages beforehand her character development had been much slower.

I feel like fans of historical fiction will like this book, particularly if you like the historical period like me. I know this is a book that some others will enjoy much more than I did but, for me, it wasn’t good enough.

3/5 stars



4 thoughts on ““City of Women” was a disappointment

  1. I too love reading books set in the WW2 period and there is nothing that annoys me more than when a book I anticipated being good – turns out to be a dog! Bummer. This doesn’t sound like a book I want to even bother with – though I will give the publisher props for the book cover. I would like to read a book set in Germany during WW2 that deals honestly with the women’s point of view during the war and how the war affected them and maybe caused them to reconsider their choices.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I know, the cover is what caught my eye at first! That and the WWII premise and it was sold to me. Didn’t hurt that it was on sale, either! But even though the premise was so interesting, it just didn’t live up to any expectations, so you’re probably better off skipping it!


  2. There are some really amazing historical fiction books out there. Sad that this one turned out to be a disappointment. 😦 I really like much older time periods. One of my favorites is Helen of Troy by Margaret George. It kept me turning pages. I was obsessed with it. It had this interesting concept of going along with myth and the Gods, but also leaving room to assume that the things that the people gave the Gods credit for were actually just done by people and stories still blossomed from it. It goes with the myth that Helen wasn’t really kidnapped by Paris, but truly loved him. Which is the version of the myth I prefer anyway. And even though we all know what happens at the end, it still came as a shock. It was just so well written.

    Sucks this wasn’t like that. But, you like WWII books? My professor writes historical fiction and he just published a book that is post WWII and takes place in Savannah if I remember correctly. And he has the Berlin trilogy which I think was 1918? Anyway that book starts with Rosa by Jonathan Rabb. It’s really good. 🙂 Not quite the same time period, much earlier, but you might enjoy it.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Ooo, I love mythology, too, so I’m definitely going to have to check that book out! I’ll have to check out your professor’s books, too! I like any recommendations so I’ll have to give them a try 😀


I read, love, and respond to each and every one of your comments! Thank you for reading!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s